• Carson Now on Facebook
  • Follow Carson Now on Twitter
  • Follow Carson Now by RSS
  • Follow Carson Now by Email

Column: Stepping into the wild horse debate, one hoof at a time

American founding father Benjamin Franklin is credited with having once said, "The first mistake made in politics is getting into it."

Here in Northern Nevada, the same could be said about jumping feet first into the debate over the Silver State's population of wild horses, an emotionally-charged, hot-button topic if there ever was one.

Fortunately, I've got many years of experience shoveling what comes out the south end of a north-bound pony.

My father gave me some sage advice the first time I walked into a sawdust-covered horse stall with pitch fork in hand.

"Watch where you step," he said.

Discussing the topic of Nevada's wild horses feels a lot like dodging dozens of stink bombs in a stall.

Stories about the wild or wild-like equines really bring the shallow, babbling brooks to the surface and out from under the rocks.

Some reader responses to recent Carson Now posts on the horses have left me scratching my head, wondering if what I had read was really an incoherent argument between immature adults, or else an elementary school playground p---ing match.

Maybe both.

The horse topic has tended to bring out the worst in Nevadans, not their best. Among our state's most polarizing issues, wild horses and their place here has long been contentious.

I'm neither a wild horse zealot nor a feral hater. I look at both sides of the debate.

On the one hand, wild horse advocates say we must protect the herds from sale and slaughter.

Fair enough. But how?

They argue that the wild horses are as much a part of the ecosystem as any other wild animal and deserve to stay.

Okay, but they are also non-native, which complicates the environment.

A standard response to anyone who suggests something must be done about the growing herds and the number of horses coming into town is, "They were here first."

Well, no, technically they were not; especially not the ferals.

The modern horse is not indigenous to North America. The first of these were introduced by 16th Century Spanish Conquistadors in Mexico and the desert Southwest.

Humans were here a lot longer before any horses. Ancestors of Tribal Americans crossed the Bering Land Bridge thousands of years earlier and settled throughout the Western Hemisphere.

The wild horse lobby also gets its dander up whenever anyone dares use the term "feral" to describe the equines.

There is a difference between truly wild and feral. Nevada has both.

To be feral is to be wild-like in behavior. Feral animals or their recent lineage were domesticated of late. That means they are familiar with human contact, having once been owned and raised privately.

A truly wild animal has never been domesticated or had any familiar human contact.

And yet, all wild horses here, at one time or another over the past five centuries, had been feral. Dating back to the Spaniards, all wild horses were once domesticated and had been used to familiar human contact.

That, of course, has changed over the centuries. But there is still a notable mix of wild mustangs and feral horses located throughout the Western United States.

Here in Northern Nevada, there are truly wild mustangs as well as estrayed or feral horses.

According to the Nevada Department of Agriculture, the herds of the Virginia Range, which runs east of Reno-Sparks from Lockwood to around USA Parkway and South to U.S. Highway 50 between Carson City and Silver Springs, include a mix of wild mustangs and feral horses. But they are predominantly feral, the state agency says.

So, too, do area horse experts, including Joe Bruno, mounted unit commander for the Carson City Sheriff's Office, with whom I recently spent part of an afternoon discussing wild horse behavior and dynamics.

But whether the horses are wild mustangs or feral equines really isn't germaine to the issue of what can be done to keep them out of town and from overpopulating the region.

We shouldn't maintain a hands-off approach to wild and feral horses. Doing nothing is as bad as doing too much.

If nothing is done to curb the growth of these herds, then more of them will find their way into town, neighborhoods, and along congested streets where they put themselves and humans in danger.

Yes, danger, as in 1,400 pounds of animal flesh striking your vehicle from seemingly out of nowhere; or charging at you because it feels threatened by the presence of too many curious onlookers crowding its space.

Don't get me wrong: I really enjoy watching the herds and bands of wild and feral horses around here. They are among my favorite photographic subjects.

But they should be encouraged to stay a healthy distance away from residential areas.

One way to do that is to avoid feeding and watering them. Wild or feral animals will find what they need on their own without any help from us.

That's really why they come so close into town. They are already searching for food and water. If we feed them, then we encourage them to stick around and invite more of their friends to the party.

This isn't safe for them or people.

Furthermore, the unchecked growth of wild and feral horses will only continue having a negative impact on the region's ecology. Indigenous herbivores — Mule deer, elk, antelope and desert bighorn sheep — must compete with these horses for the same or similar food and water sources.

The more horses there are, the greater the impact on food and water resources for other animals that were here first and that hold a much greater importance to the environment around us.

But that doesn't mean we ought to adopt extreme measures of dealing with Nevada's horse populations. I take issue with folks who think the best solution is eradication.

Why? Because horses aren't vermin, creatures that are harmful to crops, livestock or game, or that typically carry diseases.

Horses may compete for food and water, but they do not cause direct harm to other animals in the ecosystem. They are not completely useless to the environment, either.

Horse herds on state and federal lands do help to keep some overgrown vegetation mowed down; especially grasses that, when dried out after Winter and Spring moisture, can become formidable wild fire fuel.

Horse waste benefits the decomposers of the environment, too. Those organisms aren't picky from which animal the bio fuel comes out of.

And even predators, whose usual prey has moved on to seasonal feeding grounds often far away from the territories of carnivores, can stay fed just enough by preying on old, weak, sick or young horses.

Unfortunately, there aren't enough predators in the ranges where the horses roam to naturally keep their numbers in check and in balance with ecology.

The horses can contribute to nature's balance, but not when reproduction far out paces their mortality rates.

Therefore, we need solutions that support population control, because clearly nature is not achieving this on its own.

Birth control measures have been implemented before. But, truthfully, how effective have these really been in the past, and can they be made more effective if used again?

There are wild horse adoptions, too, but how many people are actually adopting them versus the number of horses in need of adoption? My hunch is the rate of the latter far outpaces the former.

Then there's hunting, a solution often scoffed at by horse advocates. It is, however, a time-tested method of helping to control animal populations.

If the state can allow hunting as a method for controlling other animal populations, then why not horses? Let the individual hunter harvest a wild or feral horse.

Require hunting tags, so that the Nevada Department of Agriculture can receive funds for the costs of managing horse herds on state land.

The meat, if not consumed by the hunter, can either be sold to those interested in a horse-meat delicacy, or else donated to homeless shelters and food pantries to feed the hungry. I imagine those in need of food would be grateful for anything they can eat.

Regardless of the population control solutions, anything proposed must be reasonable. That is, there ought to be some science behind it. Anyone can come up with a hair-brained scheme, but I believe care must be taken in order to find a balanced approach.

What do you think are the most reasonable solutions to fast-growing numbers of wild and feral horses in Nevada?

How do we institute reasonable solutions in a cost-effective manner? Someone has to pay for it, after all, and we all know who that is.

There can be reasonable solutions proposed besides a complete hands-off approach or total interference with nature. I've never been a believer in all-or-nothing thinking.

Surely, I can't be serious about all of this.

Well, yes, I can be. But I don't answer to Shirley.

Now, pardon me while I check the bottoms of my shoes.

Top Stories

... or see all stories

Greater Nevada Credit Union (GNCU) has announced the recipientsof its first Live Greater Grant program. This year, $289,000 was awarded across 37 community organizations.

Congregations of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Carson City are pleased to announce several voluntary representatives (young men and women) who have received mission calls and will soon embark on a journey of faith, service and personal growth.

Classic car shows highlight summers for chrome buffs throughout northern Nevada. A new show has been added to the mix, arriving Saturday, June 29 at the Nevada State Museum in Carson City.

The Carson City Planning Commission will hold its monthly meeting Wednesday, June 26 beginning at 5 p.m. in the Bob Crowell Board Room of the Community Center, located at 851 E. William St.

The agenda includes renewal of a proposed multifamily project permit, a radio tower appeal, among other items.

On Friday, June 28, the Carson City Sheriff’s Office will conduct an alcohol compliance checks. Underage volunteers will be sent into local businesses in Carson City and attempt to purchase alcohol using their real identification.

Cruise down US Highway 395 with local author J. Butler Kyle. Imagine your journey begins with the rugged scenery of Reno on the north end of the eastern Sierra Nevada, over mountain passes such as Deadman Summit, through unique towns along the route like Lone Pine, and down amongst the barren beauty of the Mojave Desert, to its terminus in Adelanto at Interstate-15.

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — A Tahoe City man pled guilty Monday to one count of smuggling amphibians into the United States, U.S. Attorney Phillip A. Talbert announced.

Saturated color spreads across the sky over Carson City Sunday evening.

The impact of wildfires in the Western United States on homeowners and condominium insurance will be highlighted Friday at a town hall meeting hosted by the Nevada Division of Insurance.

A 29-year-old man was arrested Saturday for suspicion of domestic battery, according to a Carson City Sheriff's Office booking report.

Mile High Jazz Band with vocalist Jakki Ford will perform two free big-band concerts in Carson City. The first, on Friday, June 28, is from 6 to 9 p.m. at Mills Park, 1111 E. William Street. It is part of the weekly Family Fun Fridays, featuring live music, food trucks, and family activities every Friday through August 9.

Every year throughout our region, pets are found dead in cars due to heat exhaustion, including those with windows cracked.

With outside temperatures often in the 90s and above, internal car temperatures can reach anywhere from 114 degrees after 10 minutes, to 140 degrees after an hour. Cracking a window often does nothing at all as rolling down the windows has been shown to have little effect on the temperature inside a car, according to the Humane Society of the U.S.

UPDATE: The 'S' on the side of the hill in southeast Carson City that commemorates the Stewart Indian School, and has been there for decades, was vandalized over the weekend. It has since been restored.

Looking for a place to take your little ones this week? Look no further! Here is a list of family-friendly (and fun!) activities and events happening this week around Carson City.

Social media awareness and the dangers that may be imposed on youth will be the focus of a parent and youth education night happening Tuesday, June 25 in Carson City.
Rugby wanted poster

The Carson Tahoe Rugby club is looking for players. The teams started back in 2019 and has grown every year and looking to have you join the team and show off your skills. Currently practice is every Thursday from 5:30 - 7:00. Reach out with any questions or for more information.

UPDATE: The fire was extinguished. NV Energy power in the area has been restored.
***
Carson City Fire Department and sheriff's deputies were called Sunday evening to a possible structure fire and brush fire in the 1200 block of Mountain Park Drive off of Marian Avenue.

Dear honorable neighbor, it’s no longer us or them. We are one big quarreling family trying to get along. Compassion lingers as our common bond, yet we sometimes bow to feelings, and mistake those feelings for thinking.

Grocery Outlet Bargain Market, the extreme-value grocery retailer, today launched its 14th Annual Independence from Hunger Food Drive, to combat food insecurity and support families in vulnerable and disadvantaged communities throughout America. From June 26 to July 31, 2024, Carson City Grocery Outlet is teaming up with the Northern Nevada Dream Center, to collect food and cash donations in-store.

Today I started pruning out the water sprouts in my four crabapple trees. Some people might call these “suckers,” but suckers grow up from the bottom of the trunk and water sprouts grow in the upper parts of the tree. I have been training three of these trees into a somewhat flattened umbrella shape for almost 20 years. The water sprouts just ruin that effect. So, out they come.

Unquestionably one of the most entertaining groups of celebrities at the pro-athlete dominated American Century Championship this year is the star-studded lineup of comedians playing in the July 10-14 edition of the tournament at Edgewood Tahoe.

The plants and trees are on their best behavior at Greenhouse Garden Center in Carson City as they celebrate their 50th anniversary of this awesome garden center, where flowers are in full bloom, trees are standing strong and tall in their pots, vendors are available to give gardening pointers, and there's lots of outdoor decor to make your garden more vibrant and interesting.

Carson City Fire Department, sheriff's deputies and Nevada State Police were called Sunday morning to a vehicle crash at the intersection of US-50, US-395 South Carson Street and I-580.

The annual Pony Express Re-ride, a re-enactment of the original Pony Express Route that spanned nearly 2,000 miles passing through what are now seven western states, returns to the Carson City area on Wednesday, June 26.

The much-anticipated Carson-Tahoe Home & Garden Show is happening this weekend, featuring an impressive array of vendors offering everything from home improvement services and products to health and beauty services and products, ensuring there is something for everyone. Admission is free to the public.

Here is the Carson City area road report for the week of June 24-30, 2024. Closures are expected at the following locations due to road and utility work:

UPDATE 9:44PM: Extinguished at around 8:45 p.m. the small brush fire was under a quarter-of an acre, said Carson City Fire Department Battalion Chief Jon Pedrini. The cause is under investigation.
***
Carson City Fire Department and sheriff's deputies were called Saturday night to a brush fire in the area of Lepire Drive in East Carson City.

Earlier this month, Dirk Roper, owner and CEO of Roper’s Heating and Air Conditioning, made the first of many deliveries of the summer of 50 fans to the Carson City Senior Center as part of the KOLOCares 2024 Fan Drive to help Carson City seniors stay cool this summer.

The USDA Forest Service Lake Tahoe Basin Management Unit is gearing up for our most popular holiday weekend, the Fourth of July. Tahoe is a cherished place, welcoming to all responsible recreationists of diverse backgrounds, and it is essential that Tahoe visitors and residents alike take care of this spectacular place to protect Tahoe’s environment and improve the Tahoe experience for all.

Here are upcoming Carson City school-related activities and local community partner events.